Anita finds American Idol entertaining. I find it mostly painful. We PVR record it, FFWD through the performances and then watch the comments from the judges[1].
This season something is happening which threatens to spin the whole thing out of control[2] – the absolutely worst contestant ever is surviving week by week because people are actually voting for him.
Meet Sanjaya Malakar. He can’t sing for fuck, but girls luurve him and he has _great_ hair – fantastic hair.

Sanjaya in Curls
He’s so bad that the judges have just about given up on saying anything real about his performances. Last nite Simon Cowell’s comment was (pointing to a crying, sobbing 12 year-old girl in the audience) ‘I think that little girl’s face says it all’.
Don’t believe me? Watch his performance on youtube.

Sanjaya does the British Invasion
And it’s not people like VoteForTheWorst.com that are keeping him there. Sure, they might think they are; but the reality is that it is Sanjaya’s real fans – real fans, that are voting for him in their millions.
Why? Here’s why.

Sanjaya makes em Cry
One of the reasons I dislike American Idol is that it has always had a conceited attitude towards the pop aesthetic and I am convinced that Simon Cowell is to blame for this.
Sure, he does understand what it takes to be a pop success, but he just cannot help himself in pushing his vision of what a great pop singer should be; soaring vocals, diva emoting and power balad performances.
In short, he’s a sucker for soul diva power performances[3].
Something Sanjaya is not.

Sanjaya does Lounge
In all the seasons up until now Simon and co. have gotten their wish. They’ve been able to steer America’s votes towards the power balad heavies and away from the power pop rubbish hotties.
But no more; Sanjaya is rubbish and the kids love it!

Sanjaya does Gwen Stefani – seriously
If he wins[4] it will be a disaster for AI’s high standards. But even if he doesn’t it still poses a serious problem for the show.
Sure, he’s popular and generates millions of votes[5] – but he’s shit to watch.
It makes for really bad television.
Of course there have been some fun that has come out of this whole thing.
Sanjaya was recently named Maxim’s Girl of the Day – yeah!
Update: Sanjaya was finally voted off last nite – Simon Cowell survives another year.
When the result was announced, Malakar wiped away tears and got a big hug from LaKisha Jones, the next lowest vote-getter.
“I’m fine,” he told Ryan Seacrest. “It was an amazing experience.”
“I can promise you: We won’t soon forget you,” Seacrest replied.